HISTORIC
AND LISTED BUILDINGS
|
Fires in historic
buildings that are workplaces not only carry a risk of loss of life
and earnings but they can also mean the loss of an irreplaceable
part of our heritage. Because these historic buildings are so valuable,
any proposed changes, including fire precautions etc, must be carefully
considered and carried out with the intention of 'minimum intervention'
in the building's fabric.
Most building
works are subject to building control under Building Regulations.
Historic and listed buildings are also subject to controls under
planning legislation. In the latter case, any proposed building
work may therefore also require listed building consent from the
planning authority. Such controls will apply in the case of any
work which could affect the character of the building, such as the
alteration of doors or door fittings to increase their fire-resistance,
the provision of new fire-resisting doors or the treatment of panelling
and internal woodwork etc.
All applications
for consent to carry out building, alteration or demolition work
on Grade I or Grade II listed buildings (Category A or B in Scotland)
will be notified by the planning authority to the Secretary of State
(or Scottish Ministers). Consent may only be granted by the planning
authority if the Secretary of State indicates that a personal determination
by the Secretary of State is not necessary in the circumstances
of the case. You should seek advice from your local building control
authority or other building approvals body at an early stage if
any building works are proposed.
It is important
to be flexible in assessing the fire safety measures that will be
appropriate for buildings in these categories, particularly when
you need to ensure that structural matters are in character with
the rest of the building. It is also important to ensure that the
work does not cause unacceptable damage to the fabric of the building.
Where a fire
certificate or some other type of fire safety approval is required
(see Annex A) it is important that you
advise the enforcing authority of all the important facts, including
the Historic or Listed Building status.
If there are
substantial practical difficulties in upgrading the building to
an acceptable standard of fire safety in the conventional way, fire
safety engineering may provide an acceptable alternative. Before
considering such a solution, you should check with the local building
control authority or other building approvals body whether this
approach is acceptable under the building legislation which applies
to your workplace.
A fire safety
engineering approach that takes the total fire safety package into
account can provide a more fundamental and economic solution than
more prescriptive approaches to fire safety.
In some instances
and particularly where members of the public are admitted, if an
adequate fire safety solution cannot be achieved without unacceptable
alteration to the fabric or character of the building, there are
two options:
limit the number of occupants in the workplace; or
stop using part of the workplace for that particular purpose.
However, an
increase in supervisory employees and effective surveillance and
supervision of evacuation procedures may, in some circumstances,
compensate for shortcomings in some structural features.
Details of specific
advice about fire precautions in historic buildings are given in
the References section.
Legislation
dealing with the needs of disabled people does not make any specific
requirements regarding means of escape in case of fire. However,
the Disability Discrimination Act 1995 requires employers to make
'reasonable adjustments' to their premises to ensure that no employee
is at a disadvantage. This includes ensuring that disabled people
can leave the premises safely in the event of fire.
As an employer,
you are therefore under an obligation to ensure that your emergency
plan takes account of disabled people. It is essential that you
identify the special needs of any disabled employees when planning
your fire safety arrangements and evacuation procedures. You will
also need to consider other less able-bodied people who may have
access to the workplace.
You may have
to take account of the difficulties people with a wide range of
physical and/or mental impairment can have in getting in and out
of the workplace (particularly in an emergency).
If any of your
employees have disabilities, your emergency plan should be developed
in conjunction with them, taking their disabilities into account.
Means of escape
for disabled people in new or altered buildings is provided for
by building regulations and, in existing buildings, by fire safety
legislation (eg the Fire Regulations and the Fire Precautions Act
etc, see Annex A).
British Standard
5588: Part 8 gives detailed guidance regarding most new or altered
buildings (see the References section).
The code should also be followed wherever possible in relation to
existing buildings. However, it is important to note that the relevant
legislation has to be complied with in the event of any conflict
with the code. The following guidance is based upon some of the
recommendations in the British Standard but the code itself should
be referred to for greater detail.
Use
of lifts as means of escape
|
Unlike normal
passenger lifts, it is essential that a lift which is to be used
to evacuate disabled people can continue to be operated with a reasonable
degree of safety when there is a fire in the building.
Although it
is not necessary to provide a lift specifically for the evacuation
of disabled people, a fire-fighting lift (see British Standard 5588:
Part 5), which is provided principally for the use of the fire service,
may be used to evacuate disabled people before the fire brigade
arrive. Another acceptable way of evacuating disabled people requiring
assistance is a passenger (evacuation) lift (see British Standards
5810 and 5655).
Normally, only
disabled people should rely on a lift as a means of escape and only
then if it is an evacuation lift specially designed for the evacuation
of disabled people as described in British Standard 5588: Part 8.
It must be under the control of the management using an agreed evacuation
procedure. The lift should be provided with a means of switching
control from general use to the car itself, so that an operator
can take it to those floors from which disabled people need to be
evacuated.
Because of the
limits on distances to be travelled for means of escape, most disabled
people should be able to reach the safety of a protected escape
route or final exit independently. However, some disabled people,
for example those who rely upon a wheelchair, will not be able to
use stairways without assistance. For these people it may be necessary
to provide refuges on all storeys other than in those small buildings
of limited height (eg where the distance of travel to a final exit
is so limited that refuges are unnecessary). You should check with
your local fire authority before considering providing refuges.
In this situation,
a refuge is an area that is both separated from the fire by fire-resisting
construction and which has access via a safe route to a storey exit.
It provides a temporarily safe space for disabled people to wait
for others to help them evacuate.
Examples of
satisfactory refuges include:
an enclosure such as a compartment, protected lobby, protected
corridor or protected stairway (see 'Technical
terms relating to means of escape' earlier in Part 3);
an area in the open air such as a flat roof, balcony, podium
or similar space which is sufficiently protected (or remote) from
any fire risk and provided with its own means of escape; and
any other arrangements which satisfy the general principles
outlined above and which provide at least an equal measure of safety.
The refuge needs
to be big enough to allow wheelchair use and to allow the user to
manoeuvre into the wheelchair space without undue difficulty. It
is essential that the location of any wheelchair spaces within refuges
does not adversely affect the means of escape for other people.
Older people
would generally benefit from facilities provided for people with
a disability in public buildings but not all are in need of them.
Only a minority of elderly people would be classified as having
a disability. It is a mistake to equate old age with physical disability,
but the age of the likely occupants will need to be considered in
any calculations for means of escape facilities.
Assisting
the less able-bodied
|
If people use
a wheelchair, or can only move about with the use of walking aids,
their disability is obvious. But disabilities can sometimes be less
obvious than this and staff should be vigilant in an emergency,
so that help can be given to those members of the public who need
it most, including the very young and the elderly. If members of
staff have disabilities, the emergency plan should be developed
in conjunction with them, taking this into account.
Assisting
wheelchair users and people with impaired mobility
|
In drawing up
an evacuation plan, you should consider how wheelchair users and
people with impaired mobility can be assisted. Some types of lift
may be used but, where stairs need to be negotiated and people with
disabilities may have to be carried, you should consider training
enough able-bodied members of staff in the correct methods of doing
so.
With a number
of individuals, their impaired mobility may only be temporary. Members
of staff in the advanced stages of pregnancy or with broken limbs
will only be temporarily affected, but you must consider their special
needs in your emergency plan.
Assisting
people with impaired vision
|
People with
impaired vision or colour perception may experience difficulty in
seeing or recognising fire safety signs. However, many people are
able to read print if it is sufficiently large and well designed
with a good, clear typeface. Signs should therefore be designed
and sited so that they can be seen easily and are readily distinguishable.
Good lighting
and the use of simple colour contrasts can also help visually impaired
people find their way around. If you need advice about this, you
can contact the Royal National Institute for the Blind or the National
Federation of the Blind of the United Kingdom (see Further
information section).
Staff with
impaired vision should be familiarised with escape routes, especially
those which are not in general use. In an evacuation of a building,
a sighted person should lead such members of staff to safety. Similar
assistance should be offered to guide dog owners, with the owner
retaining control of the dog. A normally sighted person should remain
with staff with impaired vision until the emergency is over.
In the evacuation
of the premises, it is recommended that a sighted person should
lead, inviting the other person to grasp their elbow, as this will
enable the person being assisted to walk half a step behind and
thereby gain information about doors and steps etc. Similar assistance
should be offered to guide dog owners, with the owner retaining
control of the dog.
Employees need
to be clear what to do if the guide dog remains in the building
and refuses to leave. Human life should not be put at risk if the
dog refuses to leave.
Assisting
people with impaired hearing
|
Although people
with impaired hearing may experience difficulty in hearing a fire
alarm, they may not be completely insensitive to sound; some may
be able to hear a conventional alarm signal and require no special
provision. However, where a member of staff or the public is known
to have difficulty, someone should be given the responsibility of
alerting the individual concerned. You will need to have cover for
leave and other absences. You can also get advice from the Royal
National Institute for Deaf People (see Further
information).
You should consult
your workforce before and after the installation of alternative
alarm signals because of possible unwanted side effects and to ensure
that the system is effective. Induction loop systems used in some
premises for audio communication with people using suitable hearing
aids are not acceptable as a means of alerting people with impaired
hearing in the event of fire. However, if such systems are in normal
use in your workplace, they may be used to supplement the alarm.
Assisting
people with learning difficulties or mental illness
|
Any staff with
learning difficulties or mental illness must be told what they should
do in the event of fire. Arrangements should be made to ensure that
they are assisted and reassured in a fire situation and are accompanied
to a place of safety; they should not be left unattended. Advice
may also be sought from MENCAP (see Further
information) or from local residential or day services for people
with learning difficulties.
The names and
addresses of organisations representing people with disabilities
and sensory-impaired people can be found in the Further information
section. Details of similar organisations can be found in the Yellow
Pages.
Annexes
|